Friday, November 20, 2026

"Flicker-free" LED lighting - Running LED lighting at much higher than 50/60 Hz

Several times over the course of the year I find myself "out and about" somewhere remote.  Often it's because I'm "car camping", but other times I'm involved with some sort of event - typically a long-endurance foot race - that involves activity that extends overnight.  When it gets dark, it's nice to have light and these days, the cheap and easy way to do this - and get even lighting without dark shadows - is with strings of white LED Christmas lights.

Except, they flicker.

Here in the U.S. we are fortunate that our mains frequency is 60 Hz so the flicker is a bit less noticeable than it would be in the majority of the rest of the world where 50 Hz is used.  For many inexpensive LED lightning strings, "full wave" bridge rectification - which would result in flickering at twice the mains frequency (e.g. 120 or 100 Hz for 60 or 50 Hz, respectively) - is NOT used, but rather half of the LEDs are on at any given instance:  For some strings, it is every other LED, but others fully half of the string is lit at any given time and the lower flicker rate is more noticeable.  I personally find this flicker to be rather annoying, but I can willfully ignore it, but some people find it very distracting and others say that it can cause eye strain and headaches over time.

In my experience, a lot of people people don't really notice the flicker unless it's pointed out - or perhaps they don't know how to describe it - but I find it to be somewhat distracting, so I was determined to find a "fix" for this - one that would not involve using DC, which often does not work! 1.

First, since this project involves high voltages, a few "weasel words":

This article describes the use of potentially dangerous voltages which could result in injury or death if safety measures are not taken.  If you wish to experiment with what is described below, please be careful - and if you construct or modify any of the circuits on this page, please do so with safety in mind.  As I cannot be responsible for others' actions, please do not attempt any of these unless you have experience in doing so and anything you do related to this page, you do at your own risk.

Additionally, the devices described may be suitable ONLY for powering some types of LED string lights and attempts to use them to power any other device could result in damage, injury or fire:  If you are not thoroughly familiar with electronics, high voltage safety and related aspects, you should not attempt any of the projects below.  Testing the suitability and safety of these devices for this - or any other purpose - is your responsibility.

The "audio amplifier" method

Using and abusing power transformers
 
Here, we are using the transformer "backwards", applying a lower-voltage to the secondary to produce the high voltage (about 120 volts) needed to drive the LED lights.  When using a power transformer this way, it's unlikely that it would be able to handle as much overall power nor will it produce the "expected" voltage when used this way - and there are several reasons for this.

First, the primary will have been designed to handle slightly more power than will be output by the transformer - this, to overcome losses in the magnetics (eddy currents, imperfect coupling, etc.) There will also be higher instantaneous currents due to the fact that the reactance of the windings will cause the peak current to be offset from the peak voltage (e.g. power factor) meaning that more current must be conducted by the primary than one might think.
 
Finally, to accommodate resistive and magnetic losses, the turns ratio of the primary and secondary will be offset to produce slightly higher voltage under no-load conditions so that at full power, the transformer's output will be close to the intended voltage.

Because of the above, running a transformer "backwards" (e.g. power into the secondary) will likely result in reduced voltage and lower power-handling capability than it's rating when used in the way that it was intended.

Having a decent assortment of AC power transformers kicking around I thought about using an inexpensive "Class D" audio amp module, fed with a sine wave, backfeeding the secondary winding of a transformer to get something resembling the U.S. 120 volt standard.  With this method an easily-generated sine wave - or even a square wave - could be voltage-boosted and the frequency varied to drive an LED string at whatever frequency seemed high enough to render the flicker essentially invisible.

To do this test, I ordered a TPA3116 audio amplifier module from Amazon (the total cost:  Less than US$10 for two of them) and rummaged about in my transformer collection, finding a few transformers that had 120 volt primaries and secondaries of around 6-9 volts.  At this point the reader might ask "Aren't power transformers designed for 50 or 60 Hz?" - and the answer is yes, but most power transformers will happily operate to at least ten times their designed frequency - possibly even higher - with relatively little impact on efficiency 2.

Powering the TPA3116 audio amplifier from 13 volts - which is about that which might be obtained from a "12 volt" LiFePO4 battery - I did some tests with several transformers, operating each at a different audio frequency - sourced by my trusty Wavetek 180 function generator - to determine which was the most efficient:  This set-up is depicted schematically in Figure 1, below.

For this test, I used a string of 100 warm white LEDs with a stated rating of 7.2 watts, or 60 mA at 120 volts.  As this lighting consists of a long string of series-connected LEDs, we can observe several things:

  • Figure 1:  The test set-up using a
    Class-D audio amplifier and transformer to drive an
    LED light string.
    Click on the image for a larger version.
    White LEDs, when driven to full brightness, typically need about 3 volts each, but they start to produce light (albeit very dim) at just above 2 volts.
  • Via oscilloscope measurements, the individual LEDs just start to illuminate when the voltage across this 100 light string exceeds 70 volts.
  • This string is actually three separate "sub-strings":  Two of 33 LEDs and one of 34 LEDs.  On each section of the string can be found a plastic module that typically consists of a resistor in series  with the LEDs to limit current 3.  Because LEDs are a type of diode 4 which light only when current is flowing in one direction - and it's likely that the "sub-strings" are not all be wired in the same polarity - it's likely that portions of the string will be lit at different times, depending on the instantaneous polarity of the AC waveform:  See Footnote #1, below, for more detail.

The transformer used for most testing has a 120 volt primary and a 6.3 volt, 2 amp secondary which meant that it was rated for a bit more than 12 watts.  Using this configuration, between 100Hz and 2000 Hz the Class-D audio amp pulled about 450mA at 12 volts - or around 5.4 watts to drive the LED string to a brightness that was subjectively equivalent to their being operated from 120 volts.  Below 100 Hz, the current gradually increased without any change in brightness, reaching 625mA at 60 Hz indicating that it was actually more efficient to run the transformer at a frequency much higher than its designed 60Hz.

Figure 2:  The "transformer+amp" set-up on the workbench.
In the background can be seen the driving waveform on the
output of the transformer with slight "clipping" caused both
by the LEDs conducting only on peaks and by the amp itself.
Click on the image for a larger version.

The variable frequency set-up also allowed me to subjectively determine above what frequency the LED string would appear to be "flicker-free".  As expected, 50-60Hz was "obviously flickering" to my eyes, but this effect was significantly reduced by the time the frequency was increased to 100 Hz, becoming "just perceptible".  As with many types of electronic displays - such as LED readouts - if one moved their eyes across the array of LEDs the flicker became quite apparent.

Increasing the frequency to 1 kHz makes the flicker itself imperceptible under normal circumstances and even though it can be perceived if one moves their eyes quickly across the LEDs, it is not distracting and above 2 kHz, even this effect disappears.  With the simple set-up depicted in Figure 2, the driving frequency was audible because the laminations of the transformer would vibrate slightly:  If you have sensitive hearing, you may want to consider this behavior if a constant tone is likely to be annoying.

It need not be a sine wave!

A bit more experimentation was done with this set-up with the function generator set to produce a square wave rather than a sine wave and the results were quite good:  The LED brighness increased for a given voltage - but this was expected since, unlike a sine wave, a square wave will spend half of its time fully "on", illuminating the LED rather than this occurring only at the peaks of the sine wave.  In other words, the "duty cycle" of the LED is higher.  A similar effect can be caused by intentionally overdriving the amplifier with a sine wave, causing it to "clip" and in Figure 2, a bit of such clipping is visible.  A means to generate a suitable square wave is described later in this article.

A few quick measurements indicated that while the LED string was noticeably brighter, its average current was still well within the "safe" range of typical small LEDs (e.g. well under 20 mA, average).

How many lights?

During this test I rummaged around, digging up several sets of LED lighting strings to see how many I could power with this simple set-up.  The 100 LED string depicted in Figure 2 was no problem and a second, identical 100 LED string also seemed OK, but going beyond that seemed to cause the audio amplifier to start to "buckle".

This audio amplifier, based on the Texas Instruments TPA3116 chip  is configured in "PBTL"  mode meaning that although this is a "stereo" chip, the two channels are wired in parallel as "push-pull" which, in theory, could quadruple the output power, but with just a 12 volt supply, only 10-20 watts is possible, depending on the load impedance which, itself, is determined by the properties of the transformer that is used and how many lights it's trying to power.

One issue that arises with this simple circuit has to do with the fact that LED light strings conduct only at the peak voltage - and some LED strings are more sensitive to this peak voltage.  This can result in some strings getting dimmer than others when the driving conditions change or when additional strings are added, loading down the output.  This current "peak" during the tops of the waveform also has implications to the amplifier itself:  At some point it will be unable to output the needed "peak" current and it will start to "buckle" (dropping in its ability to produce the peak power) due to this non-linear load even though it may not actually be at its maximum power ratings.  Remember:  Our LED lights are not linear loads like speakers and the amplifier will have a bit of difficulty driving them!

Something simpler?

This experimentation brought to mind that I could probably make something simpler:  What about a single-ended FET switch driven by a square wave?  Figure 3, below, shows a simplified circuit:

Figure 3:  Single-ended inverter.  The operating frequency is approx. 360 Hz with the values shown.

For this, the same transformer with the 6.3 volt, 2 amp secondary was used as above and from my junk box, and for Q1, I grabbed an N-channel power FET with a 200+ volt rating and at least an 8-10 amp current rating, mounted to a suitable heat sink.  The 1000uF capacitor (C4) is across the (nominally) 12 volt power supply to maintain low impedance for the circuit and the 10 ohm resistor with the 0.01uF capacitor form a "snubber" network that quenches some of the inductive "spike" that results from the FET turning off and the transformer's magnetic field collapsing, reducing it from well over 150 volts down to about 50 volts:  I would not omit these components.  Not shown is any sort of current limiting such as a fuse - and if you build something, I would definitely recommend it!

To drive the FET I used the ubiquitous 555 timer and the diagram in Figure 3 shows a variation from the typical 2-resistor circuit by adding a capacitor in series with pin 7 (R2) and this arrangement and resistance ratio causes the 555 timer to produce a proper, 50% duty cycle square wave:  Using the "standard" 2-resistor arrangement 6 would result in a duty cycle of significantly greater than 50% and would likely reduce efficiency and increase heating.  I have little doubt that the a bit of tweaking of the duty cycle could be done to optimize efficiency and specific loads, but the above does a pretty decent job overall.

For frequency control, capacitor C1 could be tweaked:  Using the values shown for resistors R1-R3 the oscillation frequency is around 360 Hz and if you want this frequency to remain fairly stable, it should be a plastic capacitor (polyester, mylar, etc.) rather than any sort of ceramic capacitor which could vary in value more than 2:1 over a wide temperature range.  If you wish to select a different frequency, the frequency is "more or less" inversely proportional to the value of C1 - see the article linked in the footnote for more information.

Figure 4:  Testing on the workbench.
On the scope in the background can be seen
the square-ish wave with spikes, suppressed
significantly by the snubber network.
Click on the image for a larger version.

The measured current into the LED string at the mains voltage output of the transformer was about 30 milliamps peak - or about 15 milliamps, average - well within the ratings of the LEDs and the power supply consumption was a bit over 600 milliamps - more than with the audio amplifier, but commensurate with the fact that the LED string was being driven with more current.  Adding a second, identical 100 light string reduced the brightness of the first only slightly while not quite doubling the current, but tacking a 500 light string increased the current to about 2 amps - the likely safe rating of the transformer - and dimmed the 100 light string significantly:  In actual use, both instances would be usably bright, but it showed the limits of this very simple circuit.

Because of its simplicity, the brightness of the LEDs, the voltage across them, the current through them and the power consumption of the circuit at DC will increase quite a bit with a higher supply voltage:  To provide any degree of regulation, more complexity would be required, but for the purposes of providing illumination without annoying flicker, its probably "good enough".

As a sanity check, I used a variation of the above circuit using an external function generator rather than the 555 timer so that I could vary the frequency.  With the transformer, the efficiency remained about the same from 100 Hz to 2 kHz indicating that it is remarkably insensitive to frequency variation.

If you build something like this, safety is paramount and anyone using it should be protected from high voltage and with proper fusing on the DC side.  Additionally, it should be very clearly labeled as to its purpose with warnings to not use it for anything else.  If you aren't thoroughly familiar with electronics and voltage safety, you should not try it at all!

Figure 5:  The 350 watt modified sine wave
(MSW) inverter before modification.  It's nothing
special - a cheap inverter.
Click on the image for a larger version.
Modifying a commercial inverter

As it happens I had an old 350 watt DC-AC inverter kicking around 7.  I'd bought this perhaps 20 years or so ago at Harbor Fright.  Some more modern inverters are computer-controlled, but not this one as evidenced by the fact that its output frequency was around 59.5 Hz as measured with my Fluke 87 voltmeter and slowly drifting upwards:  If it had a microcontroller, it would have been more or less "spot on" 60 Hz and would not have drifted 7.

Pulling it apart I spotted a "daughter" board that looked the the "brains" of the inverter and on it I could see that one of the chips was a 556 dual timer - two 555 timers in a single package.  Using my oscilloscope and probing the output pins (pins 5 and 9) I saw a 119 Hz waveform on pin 9 - twice the 59.5 output frequency and sure enough, there was also a 4013 dual flip-flop on this same board being used as a divide-by-two to get an exact 50% duty-cycle square wave.  A bit of further sleuthing (e.g. varying the DC supply voltage) revealed that the other half of the 556 timer (it's output on pin 5) varied in duty cycle along with that of the "modified sine wave" output of the inverter.

Figure 6:  Parts changed on the "daughter" board
to make it operate properly at nearly 10x the
original frequency - See text.
Click on the image for a larger version.
Doing a bit of reverse-engineering, I saw that the second half of the 556 timer had a 0.1uF Mylar capacitor connected to pin 12 used to set the frequency and a 0.15uF Mylar capacitor connected to pin 2 to do the "PWM control" described below:  The fact that they were the only Mylar capacitors in the circuit - and since Mylar capacitors are much more expensive than disk ceramic - was a good indication that these were part of the frequency and timing-sensitive circuit.  On a hunch I switched out the 0.1uF Mylar for a 0.01uF Mylar and the 0.15uF for a 0.01uF Mylar and found that not only was the output frequency 555 Hz (not quite 10x the original - but close), but the duty cycle control for the inverter to regulate its "average" voltage also operated properly at the new frequency.  These capacitors are shown in Figure 6, but please note that

On a "modified sine wave" inverter, it's output is NOT really a sine wave at all - and it's not just a square wave output (e.g. the AC voltage swinging positive to negative) either, but there is a "dead time" between the swing from negative to positive when the output voltage is zero, and another of the same duration when it swings from positive to negative.  For a modified sine wave inverter the goal is for the "average" voltage to remain the same over time so that the power being pulled by the load (which would ideally be resistive) would be constant, but if the power source - a 12 volt supply in this case - were to increase, the peak voltage would go up as well.  In order to maintain the same "average" power, as the supply (e.g. battery) voltage increases, the "dead time" also increases so that the voltage is output for less time - and vice-versa when the supply voltage decreases.  This is the "PWM control" property mentioned above.

For more about a "modified sine wave" and power inverters in general, see this Wikipedia article - link.

Figure 7:  Modified inverter.  Using red paint
markers on the exterior and to make the outlets
red - plus several labels - this was clearly marked
to prevent it being used for other than LED lights.
Click on the image for a larger version.

For a resistive load, the result is that the power being delivered by the inverter is, on average, constant with this method and in general, it works pretty well.  With an LED load, this will result in a variation in the duty cycle of the waveform which can cause varying brightness, but for a given load, the LED brightness says fairly constant as the DC input voltage changes.

Additionally, on the inverter pictures in Figure 7, I added some radio frequency interference (RFI) filtering to prevent it from producing interference that might impede the use of HF and VHF radios in the immediate vicinity:  These sorts of modifications are similar to those documented in a previous blog entry -  "RF Quieting a Samlex 150 watt Sine Wave Inverter" - link.  The only changes that I had to make for this modified inverter was to use 0.0047uF Class Y capacitors instead of 0.1uF Class X capacitors across the AC output:  With the higher operating frequency - and especially the square-ish wave output, a 0.1uF common-mode capacitor, during initial testing, caused a rather significant amount of extra current draw from the DC supply when unloaded because the high-frequency components of that waveform were being conducted through it:  The 0.0047uF capacitor across the output - along with the bifilar inductor and the other class-Y capacitors to ground along with filtering on the DC input of this inverter was sufficient to prevent any noticeable "QRM" (interference) when operating HF and VHF on a nearby antenna.

The advantage of modifying this commercial inverter is that it was already in a suitable case and that it was suitable for driving as many LED lights as I was likely to ever need!  While I'm skeptical that this inverter could really have handled 350 watts continuously without overheating - and I also suspect that raising its operating frequency has contributed to this "de-rating" as well - I don't doubt that it could handle at least 200 watts of LED lights:  At one public service event - a foot race in a remote mountain location that went overnight - a lot of LED strings were connected to it and it was loaded to at least 80 watts and run for over 14 hours with no problems at all.  Since then, it has also been used to power LED lighting while camping on several occasions.

Once again, unless you are thoroughly familiar with electronics and high-voltage safety,  I would recommend that you DO NOT attempt this sort of modification.

Final comments

I've used the modified inverter several times and unless you "jiggle" your eyes, the flicker is imperceptible - and I suspect that this would be true for the other methods described here as well.

As was done with the modified inverter, I would strongly recommend that it be very clearly marked as depicted in Figure 7 so that no-one  is likely to "accidentally" plug anything other than LED string lighting into it.  This method should work with practically every simple series-string LED light, but there are a few types that should not be used with this:

  • Any LED lighting with an animation or "chase" controller.  These often have a small box that controls the lighting to make it flash in a pattern or sequence.  Many of these devices have a simple controller on them that may be powered by a capacitive dropper which would be damaged by anything other than standard mains current.  Additionally, some of these lighting controllers use the mains frequency to "clock" the sequence:  That type of lights - if it works at all - would operate at many times the original animation speed.
  • Anything with a "wall wart" or voltage converter.  These types would already be powered from DC and should not flicker unless they are "animated" (e.g. "chase" or patterns) in some way.  The voltage converter may be damaged if powered from this.
  • Any sort of programmable or "smart" lighting.  Again, this type of lighting would be powered from DC and would not benefit from a higher mains frequency, and its power converter might be damaged in doing so.
  • There are commercial, 400 Hz inverters available that are intended for aeronautical purposes, and these may occasionally show up on the surplus market.   It is possible that these - if they output the correct voltage - might be usable for driving LED string lights such that they are essentially "flicker-free".

As stated in the "Weasel words" above, you do any of the above at your own risk!

* * * * * * *

Footnotes:

  1. Some of the Diode/LED sections are actually wired in opposite polarities which means that during each cycle of the AC waveform it may well be that one of the three sections of LEDs illuminates at an instant when the other two are off - and vice-versa:  This is one of the reasons why one can't necessarily resort to powering the LED string with DC rather than AC to get rid of the flicker altogether - and to do so would probably mean that only a portion of an LED string would light.  Additionally, at these elevated voltage, DC becomes quite hazardous as switches, fuses and loose connections are likely to arc dangerously as there is no "zero crossing" as found in an AC waveform for such an arc to self-extinguish.
  2. While intended to operate at 50 or 60 Hz, power transformers will typically operate fairly well at many times this frequency - even well into the kHz range.  "Slightly" higher frequencies (e.g. 100-300 Hz) may well result in higher efficiency for the transformer than the design frequency owing to lower losses in the transformer cores, but as one goes still-higher, the losses of the core can start to mount - not to mention the increased losses of the windings themselves due to "skin effect" as well as inter-winding capacitance at the very high end of the audio range.  In other words, power transformers can often be used in lieu of "real" audio transformers in vacuum tube circuits if you don't care too much about very low (<50 Hz) and very high (>5 kHz) audio frequencies - and in this application, where we are driving LEDs at mid-audio frequencies, they will work fine.
  3. The value of this resistor varies depending on the number of lights in the string, the mains voltage and how much current each LED can handle.  For the 100 light LED string depicted above, this "module" contained a 1/2 watt, 2.4k resistor.  As each string contains about 33 lights - each of which drops 3 volts, that means that when fully lit there is about 99 volts across all of the LEDs.  As a 120 volt sine wave peaks to about 155 volts, that means that during the peak of the AC cycle, 56 volts is being dropped across the 2.4k resistor and Ohm's law tells us that this equates to about 23 milliamps - well within the current tolerance of small LEDs like this, which can easily handle 20-30 milliamps:  During this peak, the instantaneous power across the resistor is about 1.3 watts - well above the 1/2 watt rating of this resistor.  Considering that the LEDs are lit only during half the cycle - and only when the voltage is swinging above 99 volts - the average LED current is actually far less than 23 milliamps and the average power dissipation of the resistor will be less than 1/2 watt.
  4. The module with the resistor will sometimes contain a diode to prevent reverse voltage from being applied to the LEDs.  In practice, this is a good idea since modern nitride LEDs (e.g. white, blue, green) will degrade very rapidly if reverse voltage is applied across them.  It would seem that the makers of LED strings have determined that, with a bunch of LEDs in series, that a diode - which would cost a few pennies - is not really necessary for a reasonable lifetime of the the light string and it is often omitted on long strings with dozens of LEDs.  On shorter strings - say, 10-15 lights - I've noticed that the diode is usually present as the "reverse" voltage on each LED would be much higher without it, along with a larger resistor capable of dropping more voltage and dissipating more power.
  5. Be careful when powering any mains-powered device from something other than a pure sine wave - or any waveform at other than a standard mains frequency.  While "resistive" devices (heaters, incandescent lamps) are forgiving in terms of how they are powered, other devices may malfunction or even be destroyed by something other than a sine wave.  In particular, devices using a "capacitive dropper" (e.g. a capacitor in series with the mains voltage to limit current) would be immediately damaged by non-sinusoidal waveforms - or even a sine wave at other than a standard mains frequency.  For example, if I had connected my "Kill-A-Watt" power monitor to any of the devices described here, it would likely be damaged immediately by a non-sinusoidal wave, not to mention too-high a frequency as either of these would permit far too much current to flow via its "capacitive dropper" circuit.
  6. A diode or two is often used along with resistors to coax the 555 timer configured as an oscillator to produce a square wave, but this shows a means by which the addition of an extra resistor can do this.  Among the places where this is described is in this article in Electronic Design Magazine from March 20, 2022, linked here.
  7. For the record, this inverter, purchased at Harbor Freight in the late 1990s or early 2000s - before this company seemed to standardize on their own "house brand" names.  It bears the "Power On Board" brand - and is apparently made by "Vector" and is part number "VEC032POB". These units can sometimes be found on EvilBay, but note that there are likely other devices out there that could be similarly-modified.
  8. It is often the case that microcontrollers' clock frequencies are controlled by a quartz crystal and as such, would be accurate to within a few hundred parts-per-million at worst.  In this case, an observable frequency shift - from a cold start and through a few minutes of warm-up - meant that we are not likely dealing with a crystal-controlled microcontroller.  If this inverter had used a microcontroller to set the frequency it would be unlikely that it could be "hacked" to operate at a frequency other than that for which it was designed.

* * * * * * *

 This article stolen from ka7oei.com

[END]


Wednesday, September 16, 2026

The Comcraft CTR-144 FM transceiver - A "multi-mode" solid state 2 Meter transceiver from the early 1970s.

Comcraft
Logo

Back in 1972 an ad appeared in the Ham magazines for something that probably seemed amazing at the time:  A solid state transceiver that covered the entire 2 meter amateur band (144-148 MHz - plus adjacent MARS and CAP frequencies) and did not need crystals!  This was the Comcraft CTR-144.  This radio cost $389.95 according to an advertisement in the January, 1972 issue of 73 magazine and was later listed at $489.95 in an ad in a 1973 73 Magazine advertisement (see Figure 6):  These prices are equivalent to over $3000 in 2026 dollars - for a two meter transceiver!

About Comcraft

Figure 1:
The Comcraft CTR-144 - a VFO solid-state 2 meter
FM/AM transceiver from the early 1970s.  A ham today
would probably be at loss when trying to use it!
The large knob is for tuning the receiver while the "VFO
Tuning" is for the transmitter frequency.  Aside from the
"tune" and "load" controls the rest are self-explanatory.
Click on the image for a larger version.

I haven't been able to find much about the Comcraft Company, other than it was in Goleta, California and that it seemed to exist from at at least 1971 until some time after 1976 when they released one of the earliest synthesized 2 meter transceivers, the CST-50.  I suspect that they may have made products for other markets, but I haven't been able find additional information.

More about the CTR-144

The CTR-144 is a "multi-mode" 2 meter transceiver in the sense that it can operate using both FM and AM - the latter being still present on the band in the early 1970s, but on its way out of common usage.  Compared to radios made since, this is an "odd duck" in that it has separate tuning for the receiver and transmitter, both using VFOs - although it can accommodate three internal and one front-panel crystal for transmit for frequently-used repeaters and those applications that required good frequency stability and accuracy (e.g. MARS, CAP).  In other words, it doesn't have a conventional switch for a +/- 600 kHz repeater offset like that of modern radios, but rather you have to tune the transmitter and receiver frequencies separately to the repeater's input and output frequencies, respectively.  Additionally, it has a built-in power supply which allows it to operate from 120 Volts AC as well as a 12 volt input and provisions for a battery pack for "portable" use.

Figure 2:
The power amplifier section of the CTR-144 - a solid-state
rig from the early 70s.  The "tune" and "load" air-variable
capacitors are visible, as is the side-mounted antenna jack.
Click on the image for a larger version.
As with some other radios recently featured on this blog, I acquired this one from a silent key friend of mine - and even into the early 2020s, he'd occasionally use this transceiver on some of the local repeaters that didn't require a subaudible tone.  It also has a very wide range "S-meter" which, unlike meters on most modern FM transceivers, would give a repeatable, reliable indication of signal strength over a range of just a microvolt or so to extremely strong. 1  Being able to operate from a 12 volt vehicle and combined with the S-meter's wide dynamic range also made it a decent receiver for direction-finding not only with a small directional antenna, but to know when one was getting very close to the transmitter itself.

About the transmitter

The transmitter isn't particularly high-power:  The specifications state that it's rated for 12 watts input power with about 6 watts out. 2 Considering the efficiency of early 1970s VHF power transistors, the output power of this transceiver is still in the range of 4-6 watts across the band, depending on frequency and supply voltage - plenty of power for local and moderate-distance repeaters when used with a modest outdoor antenna.

Figure 3:
Harmonic measurement of the Comcraft CTR-144.
Before the mid-late 70s there were no specific FCC rules
for the spectral purity of VHF transmitters, but current rules
still allow transmitters of that vintage to be used despite this.
Were it made today, the CTR-144 would not pass muster.
Click on the image for a larger version.
Out of curiosity I checked this transceiver's spectral purity on my service monitor (see Figure 3) and I wasn't terribly surprised at what I found:  While there were a few minor non-harmonic spurious emissions that were at least 40dB down from the carrier, the second harmonic was around -27 dBc - roughly 4 milliwatts.  While this would not be given a "pass" if the radio was made today (the current rules state that spurious/harmonic signals of a transmitter with 25 watts or less should be -40 dBc) there were no such rules prior to about 1977.  As noted in the current FCC rules, (§97.307(e)) a radio from this era is exempt from these rules but, if using a radio such as this causes interference, the onus is still on the amateur to resolve any issues.

If one looks at Figure 1 you'll see that there are two tuning knobs:  The larger one labeled "Tuning" - which is coupled to the slide rule that covers 144-148 MHz - is for the receiver, but the smaller one, labeled "VFO Tuning" is what sets the frequency of the transmitter and it is completely independent of the receive frequency.  What this means is that if you wish to use a repeater, the receiver is tuned to its output and the transmitter is set to its input frequency which, in the day, may have been a bit of a challenge:  The VFO Tuning (for transmit) knob doesn't have a great deal of tuning resolution on its dial so getting it "on frequency" back in the day probably meant setting the knob as close as possible visually and then getting "talked in" to the proper frequency.  When using this transceiver, my friend would have a frequency counter handy to allow him to dial in the transmit frequency precisely and monitor it for drift.

The transmit VFO itself operates from 7 to 9 MHz and this frequency is then mixed with a 65 MHz crystal to yield 72-74 MHz - and this is then doubled to the 144-148 MHz 2 Meter band.  With this scheme the transmit frequency could be reasonably stable as the most drift-prone component, the 6-9 MHz VFO, was operating at a fairly low frequency.

A close inspection of  the front panel  in Figure 1 will reveal - along the right edge of the front panel - both a "Tune" and "Load" control.  For anyone using a radio with vacuum tube finals, controls labeled thusly would be familiar, but as this transceiver has a solid state amplifier these simply provide peaking/matching for final amplifier for maximum power as indicated on the "S" meter rather than the "dip and load" of the older technology.

Figure 4:
The bottom of the CTR-144 showing the
rather hefty power transformer and, on top,
the doubler stage for the transmit chain.
The modulation autotransformer can be
seen to the left of the large, blue capacitor.
Click on the image for a larger version.
To produce frequency modulation it is the 7-9 MHz VFO itself that is modulated, but if a crystal is used, phase 3 modulation is applied to its oscillator's output prior to being multiplied by 18 via a different transmit signal path to the desired transmit frequency.  For AM, high-level modulation is accomplished by using an audio amplifier to modulate the +12 volt supply for both the final amplifier transistor and its driver via the windings of an autotransformer - a rather "old school" way of doing it, but one that eliminates the need for another, higher-voltage power supply to achieve the desired peak output power. 4

About the receiver

While schemes to up-convert a low-frequency VFO for transmitting had been used for a long time, the way this transceiver goes about receiving is a bit more interesting and complex.  While more modern analog receivers would generate a local oscillator near the receive frequency and convert the desired signal to one or more lower-frequency IF (Intermediate Frequency) stages where a single channel would get demodulated, this works more like the receive section of a transverter in that the entire 2 meter band is is down-converted to the range of 14-18 MHz using 130 MHz "doubled" from the same 65 MHz crystal as is used for transmit.

The receive VFO - the one tuned by the large knob with the frequency indicated by the slide rule - tunes across the 14-18 MHz IF to down-convert the received signal down to a fixed IF of 2 MHz where it is filtered and demodulated by a CA3075 integrated circuit.  The receiver front end itself uses some MOSFETs for amplification and mixing - a technique still used on superheterodyne receivers made today - and its sensitivity is as good as any receiver made today.

Using the CTR-144 on the air today

Figure 5:
The front end and receive section of the CTR-144.
The three-section air-variable capacitor tunes the local
that down-converts from the 14-18 MHz first IF to the 2 MHz
second IF where an integrated circuit is used for audio
demodulation.  In the upper-left is the MOSFET front-end
and filtering that give this radio good sensitivity - even by
today's standards.
Click on the image for a larger version.
Using the CTR-144 today is admittedly awkward compared to a modern radio, even if that the lack of subaudible tone for transmit wasn't an issue.  The receiver's slide-rule dial will get you "pretty close" to frequency, but unless a signal on the desired frequency is actually present you can't be certain that you have tuned "close enough".  For simplex use, once you have tuned the receiver, there is a "Spot" switch that will inject a weak signal into the receiver that you can use to tune the transmit VFO to the same frequency by listening for and zero-beating it:  In this way the transmit and receive frequencies can be set very close to each other.

Repeater operation is another matter. 5  Back in the 1970s you might have spent a few dollars to get transmit crystals for your favorite repeaters which would circumvent the problem of not knowing one's exact transmit frequency with the VFO.  But what if you didn't have a transmit crystal for the frequency?  Here, the "Spot" button is less-useful since, unless you happen to tune in someone's signal as they are transmitting to the repeater on its input frequency, there would normally be no signal at all to which you could precisely set its frequency and you may have to "sweep" around - listening for your signal's triggering the repeater, in the absence of someone else's signal.  While my friend, in later years, had a frequency counter in his ham shack so that he could precisely determine the transmit frequency, such a luxury that would have been unthinkable when this radio was first introduced. 6

Figure 6:
A Comcraft advertisement from the
April, 1973 issue of 73 Magazine.
(From the Internet Archive)
Click on it for a larger version.

Final comments

  • When I first placed this transceiver on my workbench, it worked perfectly (although I haven't tried the built-in AC power supply) aside from two of the #47 dial lamps having burnt out.
  • When the sensitivity was checked, it was only slightly deaf, but just a couple of minutes of time with the service monitor and tweaking the RF and IF stages brought it into specs.  It's interesting that while the manual (see link, below) has some "adjustment" information, it doesn't have a fully-detailed alignment procedure for the transceiver, likely because, as is true today, few people would have access to the necessary equipment to accomplish the task.  As it was, the manual and schematic informed me as to how it worked I was able to come up with a procedure "on the fly" to bring the radio back up to snuff.
  • When 2 Meter FM first appeared, the amateur community had not yet standardized on what we now call "Wide" FM (e.g. +/-5 kHz deviation).  Different channel spacings and modulation widths could be found in different parts of the country, including +/- 15 kHz deviation - particularly on UHF.  The manual for the CTR-144 specifies a deviation of +/-7.5 kHz - yet another "standard"!
  • The specified receiver bandwidth is 22 kHz which is somewhat wider than the typical 15-17 kHz for a "wide" FM receiver intended for +/-5 kHz deviation.  With this bandwidth - plus the probability of the receiver's tuned VHF frequency not being centered and an adjacent-channel repeater (15 or 20 kHz away, depending on the spacing in your area) - its use is likely to result in received interference if such a signal is present.

Comcraft CTR-144 manual

I was fortunate enough to find the manual for this transceiver in my friend's files which has been scanned and may be found at this link:  Comcraft CTR-144 Manual (35 MB, .PDF).  At the time that this blog was posted, this manual was not to be found anywhere else on the Internet.

* * * * *

Footnotes:

  1. On most FM transceivers, the S-meter will start indicating on very weak (and possibly noisy) signals and hit the "peg" (e.g. full-scale) even on a signal that is only modestly strong.  What this means is that for direction-finding purposes, most modern FM transceivers will give a "pegged" S-meter indicating even if you are some distance from the transmitter.  The CTR-144 on the other hand reaches full scale only if you happened to be right next to the transmitter while at the same time it starts indicating on a signal that is almost too weak to copy meaning that it could be used both at a great distance or in the final search for an unknown transmitter. 
  2. Until the mid-late 1970s, amateur radio power limits were specified as input power to the final amplifier stage.  This method of transmitter power was likely an artifact of the days before RF power meters were common:  It's trivial to calculate the input power to the final amplifier if one knows the current and voltage, but that isn't the case for trying to measure RF power.
  3. "Phase" modulation doesn't change the frequency directly but rather it "wiggles" the phase of the signal in accordance to the applied audio whereas actual "Frequency" modulation does change the frequency of the signal - in this case, by electrically shifting the VFO frequency:  Mathematically, the two are related since, if you could continually change the phase, frequency modulation would be the result.  With "FM" as used in the amateur service, one need only be able to modulate down to 200 Hz or so for voice meaning that with phase modulation, you could "temporarily" change the phase enough to effect a temporary de-facto frequency shift.  As the amount of change from a single phase modulator stage is quite small (perhaps +/- 60 degrees) this is usually applied at a lower frequency - in this case, at the 8 MHz crystal frequency and since this is multiplied by a factor of eighteen, our original +/-60 degrees of phase change becomes (18 * 60) 1080 degrees which is enough to appear as an adequately-modulated "FM" signal.  Mathematically, if one boosts the "highs" of the audio at a rate of 6dB per octave (e.g. doubling the deviation with every doubling of frequency) a signal generated using "true FM" is indistinguishable from one that was originally phase modulated.  In fact, it is "PM" (Phase Modulation) that we use on "FM" as amateurs:  The "highs" in the audio are boosted (e.g. "emphasized") on transmit as they are the first to get noisy with a weak signal, and on receive they are restored back to their original level (e.g. "de-emphasized") which effectively reduces the amount of noise that is heard and makes weak, noisy signals more "listenable".  When using the VFO rather than a crystal for transmit, this radio does, in fact, have to "pre-emphasize" the audio to produce "PM" and make it sound right on amateur receivers.
  4. "High-level" modulation typically refers to applying the audio to the output RF stages(s) of a transmitter by increasing/decreasing the supply voltage.  Traditionally, this was done with an audio amplifier driving modulation transformer:  On peaks with 100% modulation the voltage applied to the final amplifier is approximately doubled, yielding the  four times the peak envelope power - but it also allowed the voltage to go to near zero at the other extreme.  On this transceiver, an audio amplifier drives an auto transformer (e.g. one with a single, tapped winding).  With no modulation, the 12 volt power supply for the finals goes through it unchanged, but with audio, the transformer action allows the requisite 24-volt(ish) peaks to be applied to the amplifier stage - all without needing the complexity of a 24 volt power source.  This method was "old" even when this radio was made, but it is simple and effective.
  5. When this transceiver was made it was fairly rare for an amateur repeater to use a subaudible tone as doing so would mean that an amateur using it would not only have to have the proper crystals (for most radios of the day) but also a means to produce the needed subaudible tone frequency,  Later, in some areas subaudible tones were introduced when a geographically-adjacent repeater was on the same frequency to prevent users in an overlap area from bringing up both repeaters.  In some cases in amateur radio service, subaudible tones are used owing to occasional interference issues:  This is often considered to be a "band-aid" solution to a problem that is often due to the repeater's receive signal path not being able to adequately reject off-frequency signals (e.g. overload) - but sometimes it might be needed on a "busy" site where other users' gear isn't as well-filtered as it should be.
  6. Back in the early 1970s a frequency counter of any sort would be a somewhat rare and expensive piece of test equipment - and this would be particularly true for one that could operate at VHF!  By the late 1970s and early 1980s technology had progressed to the point where such devices were more affordable and available to the average amateur. 
 * * * * *
This page stolen from ka7oei.blogspot.com 
 
[END] 

Saturday, August 15, 2026

The Morrow CM-1 receiver - A relic of the cold war's effect on amateur radio

Figure 1:
The front panel of the Morrow CM-1 CONELRAD monitor.
The meter indicates relative signal strength and below it is the
on/off/volume control.  The dial - with a pair of "CD"
markings, is a smooth-tuning reduction drive - which is also
very accurate.  Shown here, it's on and tuned to a local station.
Click on the image for a larger version.

If you were an amateur (Ham) radio operator in the late 1950s and early 1960s, you  had a broadcast radio turned on in the background whenever you were on the air - or at least you should have!

The reason for this was spelled out in the FCC rules:  Beginning January 1, 1957, Section 12.192 required all amateur radio stations to monitor a broadcast station - at a minimum of ten minute intervals - to see if it transmitting, while they (the amateur) were on the air.  If the station had gone off the air it was then required that the amateur determine if this was because of a CONELRAD alert - and if so, immediately cease transmitting.

What was CONELRAD?

CONELRAD, short for "CONtrol of ELectromagnetic RADiation", was a system - part of the U.S. Civil Defense - where, if an imminent attack of Soviet bombers was detected, ALL radio stations - commercial (AM , FM and TV) and amateur - were to go off the air to prevent their signals from being used as beacons for navigation by the enemy.  The exception to this was that some of the AM broadcast stations were to ultimately occupy either 640 or 1240 kHz - but only for a few minutes at a time, the frequencies to be used by several different stations during that period - in a "round-robin" sort of system.  The "musical chairs" of transmitters, frequencies and locations was intended to make it difficult for the Soviet bomber to use them for navigation.

If you have seen an AM broadcast receiver intended for the U.S. market from the time period when the CONELRAD system was in existence (from about 1951 to 1963) you may have noted that at 640 and 1240 kHz there are triangular marks - often with the letters "CD" in them (the Civil Defense logo) - on the dial signifying the two CONELRAD frequencies - and these symbols are clearly visible on the tuning dial in Figure 1.  The intent of this is that civilians would tune to those frequencies to receive civil defense instructions during the "on" periods of the broadcast station near them.

Figure 2:
Rear of the CM-1.  The terminals connect to normally-open
contacts of the relay (if fitted) and the wire antenna can be
seen emerging from the chassis.  Between the two is a
potentiometer for adjusting the S-meter and relay sensitivity.
Click on the image for a larger version.

How it worked

As you might imagine, this system was cumbersome.  All stations had to be alerted in some way and "key" stations - perhaps notified via a wire service - would turn their transmitters off-on-off and on again in five second intervals and then transmit a 1 kHz tone for 15 seconds:  As transmitters of the day weren't designed to be "short-cycled" in this way, it was hard on the equipment - sometimes leading to failures.  There was also the requirement that some transmitters - and their antenna systems - change from their normal frequency to either the 640 kHz or 1240 kHz CONELRAD channel - a further complication - to participate in the on/off "round robin".

Needless to say, this system had several well-publicized false alarms as well as failures when tested over the years that it was extant.  Eventually, because of the implementation of ballistic missiles rather than piloted bombers, its reason for existing ceased in 1963.

How it affected amateur radio operators

As noted earlier, if you were an amateur radio operator, you were required to monitor a local broadcast station, while you were on the air, at least every ten minutes:  If the radio station went off the air, the idea was that you were to check for a CONELRAD alert and if it was happening, immediately stop transmitting.

Figure 3:
Top of CM-1 chassis as seen from its left side.  In the fore-
ground is the tuning capacitor, IF transformers and amplifier
tube and main filter capacitor.  The 6C4, if installed, would
be plugged in the empty socket just visible behind the tuning
capacitor.  It's well laid-out - even the audio transformer is at
an angle to minimize coupling to the AC power transformer.
The antenna wire is lightly coupled to the preselector circuit.
Click on the image for a larger version.
It's difficult to know these days how well the average amateur radio operator adhered to this rule, and for those that did, doing so certainly added a bit of complexity and awkwardness to their operating style.  A number of article appeared in the amateur radio magazines at the time describing how to "automate" the detection of the local radio station going off the air - typically by monitoring the AGC voltage of an inexpensive radio and sounding a buzzer or turning on a light.

There were also some receivers designed for just this purpose.

The Morrow Radio Mfg. CM-1

The Morrow CM-1 was one such receiver.  The receiver pictured was found among the effects of a good friend - and fellow amateur radio operator - that passed away several years ago, sitting dusty on a shelf in his basement:  I have no idea if he bought this receiver himself, or if it was a cast-off from one of the broadcast stations at which he'd worked during is lifetime.  After careful inspection, I was surprised to see that it had no bad capacitors:  The components used in its construction - particularly the capacitors - are all good-quality Cornell Dubilier (all are ceramic disk types other than the main filter) - and they seemed to be a cut above those found in a typical, cheap domestic radio of the time and it worked perfectly the first time it was turned on - and I haven't even bothered checking the tubes!  Even the main electrolytic filter capacitors are still in excellent shape - likely a result of the receiver having spent the past six-plus decades in a cool, dry basement.

Figure 4:
Schematic of the Morrow CM-1.  Despite the somewhat unusual tube line-up, it functions
the same as a typical "All American Five" superheterodyne receiver of the era, complete
with a 455 kHz IF.  The main difference is that it has provisions for connecting to an external
alarm or light based on the presence/absence of a signal using the (optional) 6C4 tube and the relay.
Click on the image for a larger version.

A "brief" circuit description 
(Refer to Figure 4)
 
While many "AA5" receivers use a resonant loop - either a ferrite stick or a coil wound on the back panel of the chassis for an antenna - the CM-1 uses just a short piece of wire, depicted in the upper-left corner of the diagram connected to C1, one half of the tuning capacitor and inductor "L1".  This and the 50-100pF series capacitor "lightly" couple a short piece of wire to the resonant circuit.  This works, but its effects can be swamped if a long piece of wire (more than a few feet/meters) is used which can spoil image rejection an cause the radio to overload on strong signals.

The 6EA6 converter doubles as both the local oscillator - its frequency determined by the other half of the tuning capacitor C2 and L2 - and mixer as it converts and amplifies the received signal to the Intermediate Frequency (IF) of 455 kHz via its plate through transformer T1 which forms a selective band-pass filter.  Following T1 is a 6BJ6 which functions as an amplifier at 455 kHz and this goes to T2, another 455 kHz IF transformer, and then to the 6AV6 diode/detector/amplifier tube.
 
The secondary output of transformer T2 applies the 455 kHz signal to a diode section and since its cathode is grounded, it causes that part of the transformer to go negative with the rectified DC voltage as well as the detected audio:  The received audio is then coupled via a 0.01uF capacitor and 10 MegOhm potentiometer to the triode section of this tube for amplification where the audio is then coupled to the plate of the 6AS5 - its grid biased slightly negative by the 220 Ohm resistor in the cathode - and amplified.  Functioning as a "Class A" single-ended audio amplifier, transformer T3 couples its high-impedance plate to the low-impedance speaker.

Referring back to the bottom of the secondary of T2 where the audio is tapped, the negative DC voltage that is also produced there is in proportion to the amount of signal getting to the 6AV6 detector tube and ultimately, the strength of the signal to which the radio is tuned.  This voltage is smoothed to remove the 455 kHz IF by a 250pF capacitor and then sent to one of the grids of the 6EA6 converter tube through the antenna-tuning inductor, L1 and also to one of the grids of the 6JB6 IF amplifier via the secondary of T1 and when the voltage gets more negative, its sensitivity is reduced.  In this way the "AVC" (Automatic Volume Control) is formed so that both weak and strong stations produce similar amounts of audio.

This same AVC voltage is also sent to the (optional) 6C4 tube:  If this voltage is very negative - as it would be with a moderately strong signal - this tube is "cut off", but if the signal disappears and the AVC voltage is less negative, it will conduct and thus turn on the (optional) relay.

For the signal level meter, a voltage divider using a 15k resistor  and 2k potentiometer (seen at the bottom of T1) sets the voltage threshold on one side of the 1 mA meter - the other side of which is connected to the cathode of the 6JB6 IF amplifier tube along with a 1k resistor to ground.  There are two mechanisms of action here for driving the meter:  If there is more signal into this tube, it conducts more current and the voltage goes up across the 1k resistor, but a higher signal will also result in a more negative AVC voltage which will negatively bias the tube and reduce the current.  It's this latter aspect that prevails:  A more-negative AVC will reduce the tube's conduction and also the voltage across the 1k resistor and when this voltage is lower than that across the 15k-2k voltage divider, the meter will move up-scale.
 
The final section is the power supply which consists of a transformer to isolate the circuit from the mains.  The high voltage is half-wave rectified by a "modern" (for the time) selenium diode and then filtered by one section of a two-part capacitor which is then decoupled by a 750 ohm resistor in series which then goes to another capacitor.  In this way, the voltage is reduced somewhat and better-filtered than it would be with just a single stage of smoothing. 

The CM-1 is a compact, tube (valve) type superheterodyne receiver from this time period that was designed to indicate when a station went off the air.  As can be seen from the photo, it looks more like a piece of ham gear than the AM broadcast band receiver in that it has a "nicer" geared (and accurate) tuning dial and a meter than indicates the relative strength of the signal to which it is tuned.

Internally, he CM-1 itself is mostly an unremarkable receiver:  Electrically, it's a variant of the "All American Five" (AA5) superhet that was produced by the millions over about four decades, but with a few interesting differences.  Sporting a power transformer, all of the tubes use six volt filaments and with the isolation, it - unlike most later, cheaper versions of the "AA5" - it does not have a "hot" chassis (e.g. one that is connected to one side of the line cord) - but with a solid-state (selenium) rectifier rather than the typical 35W4 and a rather different six volt tube line-up than a typical AA5.  A 6BE6 as the converter, 6BJ6 as the IF amplifier, 6AV6 as the detector/amp and interestingly, a 6AS5 (a tube typically used in car radios) for the audio output.  As can just be seen in Figure 5, the 6AS5's "getter" shows discoloration and Figure 3 reveals that there is a slight stain around the audio transformer where some of its wax wicked onto the chassis due to heat, both indicating that this receiver has quite a few "on" hours!

An interesting departure from a typical AA5 is its antenna connection.  Most AA5s had either a ferrite loopstick or a large coil of wire wound on the cardboard/masonite/phenolic back cover of the receiver that doubled as an RF pre-selector, but this receiver simply has a piece of wire capactively coupled to the tuning network connected to one of the capacitor's gangs.

According to the manual, only 2-3 feet (50-95cm) of wire is necessary for reception and testing of this CM-1 indicated that this was true - but it also means that one must resist the temptation to connect it to a longer wire:  Doing so simply overloads the receiver and wrecks image rejection, particularly since the front-end preselector tuning is overcoupled to the antenna itself, effectively bypassing it altogether. 

I suspect that having a really sensitive receiver was not required in this application.  When monitoring for CONELRAD, one would probably use a local station with a strong signal:  Doing so would not only help with the fact that many AM broadcast stations had to reduce their power at night, but a weak/distant station would be interfered with with the onset of nightly skywave propagation which could, at times, cause signal levels to fluctuate wildly, resulting in false alarms.

During testing - with only the 2' (50cm) wire antenna - when placed outside, I found that the receiver was capable of picking up even the weaker signals across the broadcast band, but since it is a wire rather than a coil, it's non-directional and is far more prone to pick up local "E-field" noise energy than the typical "H-field" loop which is not only directional, but offers a degree of rejection of such noise.  Practically speaking, one could probably add a loop antenna, connecting to the wire and the grounded screw (one of the two used for the relay) on the back panel to improve reception in today's modern electrical environment.

Figure 5:
The other side of the top of the chassis.  In the foreground is
the power transformer and next to it is the 6AS5 audio amp.
The socket next to the 6AS5 is for the (optional) relay, driven
by the (also optional) 6C4.  The antenna tuning coil is visible
next to the tuning capacitor, almost against the front panel.
Click on the image for a larger version.

When I first removed the receiver from its chassis I thought that it was missing two tubes as evidenced by empty sockets, but I then realized that it had a selenium rectifier accounting for there being only four tubes and immediately wondered why there were two extra sockets.  A bit of "Google-Fu" found the manual online and I learned why:   This receiver could optionally be fitted with a relay in one of the sockets (this also required another tube - a 6C4 to detect the loss of signal and drive the relay) that was intended to operate a sounder, a light or some other means of indicating loss of signal.  I find it interesting that this relay and its driver tube were omitted as shipped from the manufacturer, but I suspect that this was a cost-saving measure - and it may have been enough for most amateur radio operators using this receiver to simply glance at the front-panel signal level meter occasionally to see if a signal was still there.

Is it still useful?

The reason raison d'etre for this device ceased to be when, in 1963, the FCC rule requiring the amateur radio operator to monitor broadcast stations while operating was rescinded and removed from FCC Section 12.192, but since it's rather compact and has a speaker that dominates the top of the case means that it still works as a pretty nice AM broadcast receiver.  Whether or not one might think an AM-only receiver is still useful overall is another matter altogether!

Figure 6:
Bottom of chassis of the CM-1.  High-quality components -
including all Cornell Dubilier capacitors - are used
throughout.  The orange object left of center is the selenium
rectifier and the oscillator coil is just right of center.
Click on the image for a larger version.

The usefulness and practicality of this receiver is probably on par with most other vintage radios that one might collect and own:  They are not likely to be "everyday drivers" and more likely to sit on a shelf with other old radios - but this one, at least, has a particularly interesting bit of cold-war history behind its existence.

Follow-up:

I spoke with a good friend who was licensed in the late 1950s and he has no recollection of this requirement - but reminded me that this was almost 70 years ago!  He suspects that while the rule may have been "on the books", a lot of amateur radio operators may have simply "overlooked" the requirements spelled out in the regulations.  Since Armageddon obviously did not happen, we know - after the fact - that there was clearly no harm in not following the letter of the law, and if it did happen, would it have really mattered - and would we be still talking about it?

* * * * * * *

 This page stolen from ka7oei.blogspot.com

 

[END]

Monday, July 27, 2026

A new push-pull switch/potentiometer for the Heathkit HM-102 VSWR/Wattmeter

Figure 1:
The Heathkit HM-102 HF VSWR/Power meter.  This meter -
often found at swap meets and hamfests for low cost - is still
as useful as it was when new - and is easily repaired today,
decades after its introduction.
Click on the image for a larger version.

A few weeks ago I got my hands on a(nother) Heathkit HM-102 VSWR HF Wattmeter/SWR bridge.  This device was available from the early 1970s and into the early 1980s and was a common sight in ham shacks in the U.S.1

This unit consists of two parts:  The front panel meter/switch and the "bridge" section and it included a fairly long cable, giving the user the ability to use it as a single, stand-alone unit with the bridge mounted in the enclosure with provided screws or to have the meter and the bridge separated by several feet - often more convenient in a busy ham shack with lots of cables that cannot be conveniently routed to where the meter resides.

Repair needed!

The unit depicted in Figure 1 had belonged to a (silent key) friend of mine and due to an unfortunate set of circumstances, it was submerged for some time when the basement of his house flooded after his passing.  Amazingly, the meter movement survived unscathed - aside from a few small particles of dust that were easy to blow/brush out after carefully popping off the front  - but the rest of it needed a bit more attention.

The case itself and the knobs - once worked over with a bit of "Formula 409" cleaner and old toothbrush - were in excellent condition, as was the "SWR/2000/200" switch that selected between displaying the VSWR and forward power after it had been cleaned.  The circuit board comprising the bridge and the SO-239 coaxial connectors looked a bit "crusty" and would require a few parts, but a few minutes with an old toothbrush, some dish soap and an ultrasonic cleaner did wonders in making it look better.

What did not fare well was the combination front/panel SWR "Set" switch and potentiometer.

SWR measurement by the HM-102 and other single-meter bridges

Using a single-meter VSWR bridge is a multi-step process:

  • Transmit at a relatively low power.  If the VSWR of the load is uncertain, using a low power setting is a very good idea as it prevents possible damage to the radio and it simplifies measurements by minimizing interaction with the radio's protection circuit. 2
  • Set selector switch to "SWR" and put the potentiometer in "set" mode.  This bypasses the wattmeter's calibration, allowing the user to set the meter and is accomplished on the HM-102 by pulling on the "Set" switch.
  • Set the meter to full scale.  This sets the meter so that the full scale is relative to the current forward power to allow a direct comparison of the reflected power and thus the VSWR.
  • Take the meter out of "set" or "calibrate" mode.  With the forward power calibrated, the meter will now directly read SWR on the appropriate scale.  On the HM-102, this is done by pushing on the "Set" switch and then, the VSWR can be directly read from the meter's scale.

For the HM-102, the "set/calibrate" function uses a "push-pull" switch on a potentiometer, and as Figure 2 shows, this assembly did not survive.  This type of switch was ubiquitous in the 50s through the 70s, found on radios and televisions as well as many other consumer electronic devices, but it has all but disappeared in recent decades and I thought that finding a suitable replacement might be difficult.

Figure 2:
The remains of the original push-pull switch/potentiometer.
The aluminum shaft had seized/galled to the aluminum
bushing and efforts to free it resulted in its eventual
destruction - although it was likely already a lost cause.
Click on the image for a larger version.

While I figured that it was a long shot, I initially tried several things:  Some "PB Blaster" as well as some heating/cooling cycles, but it became apparent that even if I had been able to free the potentiometer shaft that had seized to the bushing, both the potentiometer and the switch itself were likely to have been destroyed by my attempts to free it, if not having been submerged in water.

For a few days I wasn't sure what I might do to find a replacement:  I rummaged around in my collection of potentiometers and while I found one or two "push/pull" units with an integrated switch, none of them were anywhere near the needed 200k-Ohm value.

The Internet to the rescue

On an impulse, I decided to check the parts suppliers like Mouser and DigiKey and was surprised to find out that these devices were still readily available.  On a whim, I also checked Amazon for a "push-pull potentiometer switch" and was greeted with dozens of options:  I'd managed to overlook the possibility that such switches would still be sold as replacement in other gear - namely certain brands of guitar amplifiers.

A bit of further searching showed that the two most common values of these potentiometers seemed to be 500k and 250k - the latter being "close enough" to the original 200k part that it shouldn't really matter 3.  While most of these devices have shafts for splined knobs - which would have sufficed even with the setscrew knob of the HM-102 - I did find on Amazon a Bourns unit (P/N:  PDB183-GTR02-254A2 - which I also found at Digi-Key) that had a "smooth" 1/4" shaft and ordered that .  The cost:  About US$13 or so, including shipping - cheaper that the other parts suppliers, and faster delivery, too.

Figure 3:
The new push/pull potentiometer/switch installed in the re-
furbished HM-102.  This is the Bourns P/N
PDB183-GTR02-254A2 - still readily available.
Just visible in the photo is a 1.3 MegOhm resistor across the
terminals to bring the maximum value closer to the 200k-
Ohms of the original device and this may help to make it
slightly less "touchy" during adjustment.
Click on the image for a larger version.

When it arrived a few days later it was a perfect fit with the shim/spacer of the original switch/potentiometer.  As this potentiometer was intended for stereo audio, it has two independent sections - and the switch itself was a DPDT - so only half of the device needed to be wired up.

Getting it working again

The only other casualties were on the bridge's PC board:  The 2-20 pF trimmer capacitor was seized and the 50k board-mounted trimmer potentiometer was too "flaky" to be trusted.  It so-happened that I had an exact replacement for the capacitor and found a very similar trimmer potentiometer in my collection that was 60k - close enough.  Spending a few minutes with a dummy load, I was then able to null the VSWR bridge and calibrate the meter as described in the manual.

A quick test showed that the power meter was within specifications and the VSWR bridge's balance was good from at least 80 through 10 meters when spot-checked.

Conclusion

At first, I thought that this vintage HM-102 might have been parted out and/or consigned to the trash can, but with only a bit of work and a few parts, it was resurrected and cleaned up.  Aside from a few scuffs revealing the fact that it had, in fact, been used for some time, it works well and it looks very good for a piece of electronics that is a half-century old and had been nearly drowned!

 * * *

Footnotes:

  1. The HM-102 - which is designed to work from 1.8 through 30 MHz - appears to have been introduced around 1972 when the kit cost $29.95 while in 1981, the kit cost $49.95 and was apparently discontinued after that.  There was also a VHF version for 6 and 2 meters - the HM-2102 - that looks very similar and in terms of mechanical design and much of the above discussion could be applied to it as well - and it even uses the same potentiometer/switch as the HM-102.  There was also a version of this device with two meters - one for forward power and the other for reverse power/VSWR.
  2. Modern radios have "fold-back" circuitry to automatically reduce power if they "see" a high VSWR.  It is best to set the transmitter to low power if the VSWR is unknown (say, 5-10 watts on a 100 watt radio) as even the best protection circuit isn't completely able to protect the radio under all conditions - particularly if one is using an external antenna tuner and forgetting to reduce the power level.  Setting the radio to a low power output during tuning prevents the fold-back circuit from activating as much:  If the radio had been set to high power, the output power will rise rapidly as one attains a better match (e.g. when using a manual tuner) and the user will have to frequently re-set the SWR to full scale to obtain an accurate reading and possibly confusing the operator - but at low power, this complication is minimized.  Practically speaking, keeping one eye on the reverse power - and minimizing it - while keeping another on the radio's wattmeter will make quick work of adjusting whatever manual antenna tuner you might use.
  3. The original potentiometer/switch was 200k, but the modern replacements are only readily available as 250k devices with a logarithmic taper.  This higher value and possibly the logarithmic taper may make this control - which is simply placed in series with the front-panel meter - a bit "touchier" than the original when it is adjusted at some power levels.  Placing a 1.2-1.5 MegOhm fixed resistor (the precise value is unimportant) across the potentiometer connections will reduce its maximum value to about 200k and make this adjustment slightly less "touchy".  If you have a meter like this but can find only the 500k version of the potentiometer, go ahead and use it anyway - just place a 330k fixed resistor across its two connections to limit its maximum value to about 200k:  It, too, may be a bit "touchy", but it will work.
     

* * * * * *

This page stolen from ka7oei.blogspot.com

[END]